View
Growth & Marketing

Brand vs performance marketing:we optimised everything except how it feels

Performance marketing still works. It has just stopped doing the brand’s job. Learn how growth teams can buy attention and memory with one budget.

Written byToni Dada
Published
Reading time6 min read
Send App ads by Flutterwave: a performance creative (left) and the curiosity-led carousel (right).

A trick I play on new clients. I take their best-performing ad out of rotation and replace it with a plain, curiosity-led carousel. No discount. No countdown. Just a question they have not been asked before.

Engagement multiplies. Every time. The comments fill up, people stop scrolling past, and some of them ask what we actually sell.

It is not clever. It works because of what it is standing next to. Everything around it is shouting.

50% OFF. CLICK NOW. LAST CHANCE.

Ads used to whisper. They pulled you in with intrigue and tension and let you arrive at the product yourself. Now they demand, and the demanding is getting more expensive every year.

Remember what the old ads were actually selling

Apple’s 1984 ad never mentioned a specification. It made you feel like you were joining something.

Nike’s Find Your Greatness never said buy shoes. It said you are already the kind of person who does this.

Coca-Cola’s Christmas work never said shop now. It sold warmth, and it sold it so consistently that the lorry became the start of the season for a generation.

Closer to home, I can still hear the Mirinda ad. Not a line from it. The sound someone makes when the cold drink hits. Ahhh. Thirty seconds of film that sold a feeling, and the product arrived as the obvious way to get it.

None of these played for the click. They built something so solid that buying became inevitable.

Give performance marketing its due

Direct response works. It is trackable, it scales, and it tells you within hours whether you were wrong. I have built growth engines on it and I will build more.

The problem is not the discipline. The problem is what happens when it becomes the only discipline.

Nobody wakes up hoping to see a retargeting ad. They wake up thinking about their problems, their ambitions and their distractions. A brand that only ever shows up at the moment of purchase is betting everything on being in the right place at a moment it does not control.

So three things happen.

  • Media gets more expensive. Predictable ads get ignored, ignored ads need more impressions, and more impressions cost more money. Rising CPMs are partly auction dynamics and partly the market quietly telling you your creative is boring.

  • Customers stop being yours. Win someone with a discount and you have taught them that price is the relationship. The next discount takes them.

  • Discovery dies. Most of the value in an ad happens in the moment someone sees it, does not click, and remembers it three weeks later. If you only count clicks, that moment looks like waste, so you optimise it away.

Les Binet and Peter Field’s IPA work puts the optimal split at roughly 60% brand building to 40% sales activation, and found that emotional campaigns are almost twice as likely to deliver top-tier profit growth over the long run. Most of the budgets I see in this market run closer to 95:5.

Why this costs more in African markets

Everything above is true everywhere. Here it bites harder, for reasons that have nothing to do with creativity.

Trust is the gate

In markets where people have been burned by businesses that took the money and vanished, familiarity is not a nice-to-have. It is the thing that makes the first transaction possible at all. An unknown brand with a 50% discount reads as a risk, not a bargain.

Categories are still being created

A lot of what my clients sell has no established habit behind it. You are not winning share from a competitor, you are explaining why anyone should do this at all. That is brand work, and no amount of retargeting substitutes for it.

The buying journey leaves the platform

It continues on WhatsApp, in a group chat, with an agent, at a distributor’s shop. None of that attributes. If your dashboard is the only thing you trust, you will defund the part of the funnel that is actually working.

Word of mouth carries further than paid

Which means what people remember about you, and how they describe you to someone else, is doing more selling than your ad account is.

Bring the tension back

Not by spending less on performance. By making performance do two jobs instead of one.

Lead with the story, then the offer

Instead of "50% off our skincare set", try "Ten thousand women switched last year. Here is what changed." Make someone curious before you make them convert. The offer still comes. It just stops being the opening line.

Sequence it

Run something that earns attention. Retarget with something useful rather than something urgent. Make the offer third. The best growth engines are not choosing between awareness and conversion, they are running one into the other on purpose.

Write a call to action someone can feel

"Buy now" asks for a transaction. "This will change how you do X" asks for a decision. One of those gets remembered.

Measure the thing you are actually buying

If you only instrument clicks, brand work will always look like a cost. Branded search volume, direct traffic, unprompted recall and the share of new customers who arrive already knowing what you do are all measurable. We field recall and message tests through Mooyi, our own panel across African markets, because asking people is cheaper than guessing and faster than waiting for the quarter to end.

Stop treating it as a choice

When we rebuilt growth at Kuda, the user number went from 150,000 to a million in four months. The paid media mattered. So did a channel nobody else was looking at, and tracking that finally told the truth, and a proposition people could repeat to a friend without a landing page in front of them. Pull any one of those out and the number does not happen.

Marketing is not broken. It is over-optimised for the half of the job that is easy to count.

Before the next ad goes live, three questions. Does it make anyone feel something. Does it leave a gap someone wants closed. Will a single person remember it tomorrow.

If the answer is no three times, you have not bought attention. You have rented a click.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between brand and performance marketing?

Performance marketing buys an action now and measures it directly: a click, a signup, a sale. Brand marketing buys memory, so that when someone is ready to act, you are the option they already trust. Performance captures demand. Brand creates it. Most companies need both and fund only one.

What is the right split between brand and performance marketing?

Binet and Field’s IPA research puts the long-run optimum at around 60% brand to 40% activation across a broad set of categories. Treat that as a direction rather than a rule. An early-stage company with no product-market fit should not be spending 60% of a thin budget on awareness, and a mature brand running at 95% activation is almost certainly leaving profit on the table.

Does brand marketing make sense for an early-stage company?

Not as a separate budget line, no. It makes sense as a standard you apply to the performance budget you are already spending. The same naira buys a forgettable ad or a memorable one. Only one of them is still working for you next quarter.

Why are my CPMs rising?

Part of it is auction competition, which you do not control. Part of it is ad fatigue, which you do. Platforms charge more to deliver creative that people scroll past, so predictable, offer-led work gets structurally more expensive over time. If your CPMs are climbing faster than your category’s, creative is usually the first place to look.

How do you measure brand marketing without waiting a year?

Branded search volume, direct and organic traffic, the share of new customers who already know what you do, and prompted and unprompted recall tested against a consistent sample. The last one needs a panel. The first three are already in tools you own.

Toni DadaToni is the founder of Enterscale, a growth consultancy working with founders and senior marketing teams across African markets. If something is working and you cannot explain why, or your CPMs are climbing and nobody can say what changed, book a call. Thirty minutes, and you will leave knowing what is blocking you.
Next stepThirty minutes, no presentation
Book a call →