View
Growth & Marketing

In-house marketing or an agency?You are asking the wrong question

In-house marketing gives you control. An agency gives you range. Here is how to work out which is more likely to help with growth at your stage.

Written byToni Dada
Published
Reading time6 min read
Founder weighing in-house marketing against hiring an agency

I get asked this question every now and then. Usually, once a founder has successfully raised growth funding, or a CMO has a budget approved and a growth target with a date on it. Build a team, or hire an agency? They want to know which one I would do.

I never answer straight away. Both quotes tell me who would do the work. Neither tells me what is wrong.

Give each option its due

Start with what each is genuinely good at, because most articles on this subject are written by one of the two and it shows.

What in-house is best at

  • Control over how the brand sounds, every day, without a brief.

  • Knowledge that stays. The person who learned why the last launch failed is still there for the next one.

  • Proximity to product and sales, which is where most real growth insight comes from.

The catch: a small team can only be good at a few things, and they are the few things you happened to hire for.

What an agency is best at

  • Range. Twenty specialists you could never justify employing.

  • Pattern recognition across clients, which is worth more than it sounds.

  • Speed on anything they already do at volume.

The catch: you are one account among several, and they are paid to run the brief rather than to question it.

Neither list is wrong. A company with a complicated product and a long sales cycle is usually better off in-house, because the learning compounds in people who stay. A company that needs performance creative produced at volume is usually better off with an agency, because you are buying a machine somebody else has already built.

Notice what the question assumes

Both options answer the same question: who should we employ. Neither one answers the question underneath it, which is who is going to decide what gets done.

This is why the failures look so similar. The in-house team that produces a lot of activity in no particular direction. The agency that runs the brief beautifully and never asks whether the brief was right. In both cases the execution was fine. Nobody was steering.

It is also why the two options get swapped for each other so often. A founder hires an agency, gets frustrated, brings it in-house, gets frustrated, and goes back out again eighteen months later having changed the staffing twice and the thinking not at all.

Work out which part is actually broken

Before you choose a model, name the gap. In practice there are only three, and they need different things.

A direction gap

You have people who can do the work and no agreement on what the work should be. Everyone is busy, the output is reasonable, and the numbers do not move. Hiring an agency adds more output to a system that already has too much. This needs someone senior with the authority to stop things.

A capacity gap

You know exactly what to do and nobody has time to do it. This is the one case where an agency is straightforwardly the right answer, and where founders hesitate for no good reason.

A craft gap

The plan is right, the hands are there, and the work is not good enough. A specialist fixes this, in-house or out. It is the cheapest of the three to solve and the one most often mistaken for the other two.

Most companies that come to us have the first one and have been buying solutions to the second.

Build the answer around the work, not the org chart

There is a third shape, and it is becoming common enough that people have started calling it a growth studio: a small senior team that works inside your company for a defined period, sets the direction, runs the work alongside your people, and hands over a process your team can keep running. Not a department, and not a supplier.

What makes it different is not the staffing. It is that the engagement is defined by an outcome rather than by a function. An agency is bought by channel. A team is hired by role. This is bought by the thing you are trying to make happen, which means the scope can change when the evidence does.

At Enterscale it takes one of two forms, and the first week is the same either way. We spend it on a diagnostic: which stage you are in, what is blocking the next one, and whether the thing you came to us for is actually the problem. Then either your team does the work with us setting the process and holding the standard, or we work inside your growth function against a number you set. Decide who does the work, in other words, rather than who signs the contract.

We are not an ad agency, and we do not try to be one. We run no more than four engagements at a time, which is a real constraint and sometimes means we don't have an answer yet.

See what that looks like in practice

Three from the last few years.

A challenger bank with product-market fit and no growth infrastructure

Kuda had no reliable tracking, no North Star metric the company shared, no growth team, and a stack of technical SEO faults suppressing organic discovery. We rebuilt product and marketing analytics, set a North Star the whole company could name, cleared the SEO, restarted paid with sharper targeting, and opened a device channel on Huawei and Xiaomi that no African fintech was looking at. Users went from 150,000 to a million in four months. Then we hired and coached their own growth team, which is the part that mattered most, because the work carried on after we left.

An investment bank building a retail product

We supported the digital transformation team at InvestNaija by Chapel Hill Denham, working across functions to turn a retail investment proposition into user and operational requirements that held up in practice, then helped plan how it went to market.

A payments company entering new markets

We launched and scaled paid acquisition for Flutterwave across Anglophone and Francophone Africa, testing copy, creative and targeting on a fortnightly cycle until the cost per signup came down and stayed down. Spend fell while signups rose steadily.

None of those were a channel brief. Each started with finding out what was actually stopping growth, which is a different job from being asked to run ads.

Frequently asked questions

Is in-house marketing cheaper than an agency?

Rarely, once you count properly. Salaries, pension, health cover, tools, recruitment and the months a new hire spends getting useful usually add up to more than a retainer for the same output. In-house is better value when the knowledge compounds, not when the headcount is small.

What is a growth studio?

A growth studio is a small senior team that works inside a company for a defined period, sets the growth strategy, runs the work alongside the internal team, and hands over a process the company can keep running. It sits between hiring in-house and appointing an agency.

Can I use an agency and an in-house team together?

Yes, and most companies past early traction do. The arrangement works when someone internal owns the strategy and the agency owns a channel inside it. It fails when the agency is quietly setting the strategy because nobody internal has time to.

When should a startup build an in-house marketing team?

When you know which channels work and why. Hiring before that means paying people to run experiments you could have bought, and it locks your cost base to a plan you have not validated. Once a channel repeats at a cost you can defend, bring it in.

How do I stop this decision going wrong again?

Write down what you expect to be different in ninety days before you sign anything, and who inside your company owns it. Most of the in-house and agency disappointments we see were predictable at the point of contracting, not at the point of delivery.

Toni DadaToni Dada is the founder of Enterscale, a growth consultancy working with founders and senior marketing teams across African markets. If you are weighing a team against an agency, bring the number you are being measured on and book a call. Thirty minutes, no presentation, and no proposal until you ask for one.
Next stepThirty minutes, no presentation
Book a call →